Josh Hutcherson's Controversial New HBO Show Sparks Fierce Critic & Audience Divide

The HBO series I Love LA premiered on November 2, quickly sparking mixed reactions from critics and viewers on Rotten Tomatoes after just one episode. Created by Rachel Sennott, the comedy focuses on a close-knit group of friends reuniting after years apart, highlighting how those years have changed them.

Critical Reception

Critics have largely praised I Love LA, commending its absurdist humor and appeal to Gen Z sensibilities. The show currently holds an 81% Certified Fresh rating based on 32 reviews.

Sam Adams of Slate notes the show's “writing gets sharper” as it progresses and appreciates the deep characterization of the main cast.

Chris Vognar from the Boston Globe highlights how the series successfully renders unlikable protagonists sympathetic.

Audience Reaction

Audience opinions are more divided, with the show holding a 59% score from fewer than 50 ratings on Rotten Tomatoes. While some viewers have given five-star reviews praising its humor and modern relevance, others criticize its clichéd depiction of Los Angeles and unsuccessful emotional moments.

Summary of Responses

Strong critical acclaim for writing and character depth
Diverse audience reactions ranging from high praise to disappointment
Debate centers on humor style and emotional sincerity

Despite mixed reviews, positive critical feedback currently outweighs audience criticism.

Author's summary: Josh Hutcherson’s HBO comedy I Love LA divides critics and viewers sharply, praised for smart writing yet criticized for clichés and emotional missteps.

Screen Rant — 2025-11-07