In 1932 and 1980, the United States experienced major ideological transformations that lasted for years. During those times, political shifts were significant but steady. In contrast, the 21st century has brought frequent changes in direction, a restless movement from one pole to another.
The events of Tuesday were consequential. Historically, when America made a sharp political turn—left in 1932 or right in 1980—it usually stayed on that path for some time before settling toward the center. Now, our politics swing more wildly, perhaps showing vigor and openness or, conversely, instability and confusion.
“Whichever, we’re lurching, and afterward trying to understand our own logic.”
Modern conservatives, the author notes, often prefer art, culture, and technology to be lively, while government should remain steady and predictable—a calm backdrop amid constant activity. Yet today, even government is far from boring, and this volatility is unlikely to fade soon.
Turning to Tuesday night’s election results and the Democratic sweep, the author attributes the outcome partly to President Donald Trump—his approach and personality shape nearly everything in politics. His workplace immigration raids, once cautioned against, alienated even some supporters. Hispanic voters, previously leaning right, shifted decisively back to the left.
Equally important were rising costs and a growing sense that the government is not addressing everyday economic struggles. Many voters now feel their personal stability is uncertain, fragile, and temporary.
The essay reflects on America’s frequent political swings, linking them to instability, voter frustration, and reactions to leadership under President Trump.