Is Israel about to lose its magic?

Is Israel about to lose its magic?

The Israeli government's proposals for a new Basic Law on national identity and the nation-state have sparked heated debate and protests.

The proposed law, which was submitted to the Knesset, the Israeli parliament, in January, would enshrine in law the definition of Israel as the "nation-state of the Jewish people" and would potentially restrict the rights of non-Jewish citizens, particularly the Arab minority.

The proposal has been widely criticized by Arab-Israeli lawmakers, human rights groups, and some Israeli Jews, who argue that it would further entrench Israel's apartheid policies and create a "Jewish state" that discriminates against non-Jews.

"This is not just a question of equality, but of the very essence of democracy," said Mohammad Barakeh, the leader of the Hadash party, in a statement.

The proposed law would, among other things, make it easier for Jewish settlers to be granted Israeli citizenship and would potentially allow the state to take land from Arab citizens and transfer it to Jewish settlers.

The Israeli government has argued that the law is necessary to protect Israel's " Jewish character" and to prevent the erosion of its Jewish identity.

However, many critics argue that the law is an attempt to create a "Jewish state" that discriminates against non-Jews and would further entrench Israel's occupation of the West Bank and the Gaza Strip.

"This law is a declaration of war on democracy and human rights," said Ahmad Tibbi, a Palestinian Israeli journalist.

The proposed law has sparked widespread protests across Israel, including in Tel Aviv, Jerusalem, and Haifa.

As the debate rages on, many are left wondering: is Israel about to lose its magic?

Will the proposed law further entrench Israel's apartheid policies, or will it lead to a more just and equal society for all citizens?

Only time will tell.

Automatic summary

Israel's proposed Basic Law on national identity and the nation-state has sparked heated debate and protests, with critics arguing that it would create a "Jewish state" that discriminates against non-Jews.

more

Unpacked Unpacked — 2025-11-24

More News